A Comparison of Regional Oxidant Model (ROM) Output with Observed Ozone Data (1998)

Abstract:

The output from the Regional Oxidant Model (ROM) is compared to ob­served ozone over Northern Illinois for June, July and August 1987. The 8-hour daily average at the ozone monitoring stations is interpolated to the ROM grid cells using a spatial statistical method. Differences between the model out­put and spatial predictions are compared at three levels of spatial averaging (grid cell, 6 x 6 block , 4 blocks) and three levels of temporal averaging (daily, weekly, 3 months). In addition two monitoring stations are paired with )Weather stations and ROM cells in order to investigate the performance of ROM as a function of meteorological conditions. For daily values the root mean squared error (RMSE) between the ROM values and those predicted from the moni­toring network varies between 14 and 25 PPB with the largest discrepancies occurring near Lake Michigan. Weekly averages reduce the RMSE by approxi­mately 30% but spatial aggregation is not helpful in improving the agreement. The difference between ROM and the two paired sites depends most strongly on temperature and to a lesser extent on dew point temperature. The R2 from lin­ear regressions is approximately 35% . Typically ROM is found to over predict ozone under cool, cloudy conditions. An examination of the synoptic-scale and mesa-scale weather patterns during this period indicates that ROM is sensitive to dynamic situations such as a frontal passage. 

Keywords:

Ozone, Model Validation 

Author: 
Jerry M. DavisDouglas Nychka
Publication Date: 
Friday, May 1, 1998
File Attachment: 
PDF icon tr85.pdf
Report Number: 
85